Picture yourself standing at a crossroad, facing a decision that could change your future. Whether it’s a question of career path choice, diagnosing a patient, or even the best route to take to drive to another city, all of these could feel really overwhelming. Yet, astonishingly, the brain can break down the most complicated of decisions into components. Recent research from neuroscientists at MIT begins to explain how our brain pulls off this remarkable feat. 

Hierarchy of Choices in the Brain 

Complex decisions frequently consist of a hierarchy of smaller steps. Consider a doctor treating a patient. The doctor might first choose a diagnostic test, interpret the results, and then prescribe a treatment. Each step follows from the one before in a logical order. What happens when things go wrong? And if the patient doesn’t get better, well, at which exact point did it go wrong? Was it a wrong test or wrong treatment? It’s that type of question, and it does involve quite subtle reasoning, but the brain is seemingly wired to do that, according to the MIT study. The whole mechanism centers around measuring confidence. Our brain calculates the possibility of failure for every point to isolate the weak link in the chain when a decision leads to a not-so-great outcome; if clarity isn’t achieved, it circles back, gathering more information. The ability of the mind to navigate through hierarchies while reasoning over outcomes-one of the exciting frontiers of cognitive neuroscience-says Mehrdad Jazayeri, the senior author of the study. 

Confidence Breaking Down Complexity 

How would the researchers manage to disentangle this cognitive Gordian knot? The experiment the researchers designed was really ingenious. Animals had to make one of two eye movements depending on whether the time interval between two flashes of light was shorter or longer than 850 milliseconds. However, there was a catch: the rule that determined the correct eye movement switched covertly after a series of trials. To succeed, the animals needed to infer the rule, then make judgments of the interval and so choose. The animals used an error as an opportunity for learning. They must reason that perhaps they misjudged the interval this time or perhaps the rule had indeed switched. There is an elegant interaction between confidence and behaviour. It can be seen that when timing intervals are well judged, when easy, animals adjust more quickly after a mistake. But when the interval was more difficult to detect, they were hesitant; attempting to apply the same rule a few more times before changing. That is pretty similar to how humans behave under uncertainty-we become more conservative and change choices over time before finally making a decision. 

A Circuit for Rational Thinking 

Later in the study, neural activity was recorded in two regions of the frontal cortex, including the anterior cingulate cortex and the dorsomedial frontal cortex. These regions lit up when the animals made an error, indicating their belief about whether a rule switch had occurred. Activity in the ACC was especially heightened following easy trials or consecutive errors, predicting when the animals would switch strategies. The researchers then used optogenetic manipulation of neural activity in the ACC to show its necessity in driving this type of decision-making. Interfering with this region impaired the animals’ ability to rationally adjust their behaviour, which emphasized the key role of the ACC in adapting to new information. 

Lessons for Life and Learning 

The insights this study offers into the workings of the brain go much deeper than just increasing our knowledge about the brain but also offer some serious insights into how we deal with everyday life and its complex problems. When failure happens, the brain’s strategy to break down decisions into smaller components and evaluating confidence can serve as a model for better decision-making: 

  • Root Out the Problem: Just as the brain identifies the most probable cause of failure, we can analyze where things might have gone wrong in our own decision-making processes. 
  • Assess Confidence: Know when to say you don’t know and go out to gather more information instead of making a hasty decision. 
  • Adapt and Persevere: Change strategies when the evidence calls for a different course; don’t change course too hastily because confidence is low. 

The Art of Simplification 

There’s a magical way our brains can simplify complexity in this paralyzing world of choice. By developing a hierarchy of choices, we are confident to make appropriate judgments at each juncture with crystal clarity on the most complex challenges. This mental framework is more than a tool for neuroscientists; it’s a guide to all of us in facing the uncertainties of life. So the next time you’re overwhelmed by a tough decision, remember: your brain is wired to break it down. Trust the process, analyze your confidence, and let your mind’s natural hierarchy guide you toward the best path forward.

Dr. Prahlada N.B
MBBS (JJMMC), MS (PGIMER, Chandigarh). 
MBA in Healthcare & Hospital Management (BITS, Pilani), 
Postgraduate Certificate in Technology Leadership and Innovation (MIT, USA)
Executive Programme in Strategic Management (IIM, Lucknow)
Senior Management Programme in Healthcare Management (IIM, Kozhikode)
Advanced Certificate in AI for Digital Health and Imaging Program (IISc, Bengaluru). 

Senior Professor and former Head, 
Department of ENT-Head & Neck Surgery, Skull Base Surgery, Cochlear Implant Surgery. 
Basaveshwara Medical College & Hospital, Chitradurga, Karnataka, India. 

My Vision: I don’t want to be a genius.  I want to be a person with a bundle of experience. 

My Mission: Help others achieve their life’s objectives in my presence or absence!

My Values:  Creating value for others. 

Leave a reply