In a country like India, where healthcare costs are escalating at an alarming rate and medical emergencies can lead to financial devastation, securing comprehensive health insurance is no longer a choice but a necessity. With healthcare inflation climbing at 14% annually and most Indians facing the risk of financial ruin due to medical bills, the need for well-rounded health insurance plans is more urgent than ever. As highlighted by Nithin Kamath, co-founder of Zerodha, the reality is stark—many Indians are just “one hospitalization away from bankruptcy.”
The complexities of the health insurance sector, from claim settlement ratios (CSR) to network hospitals and incurred claim ratios (ICR), add to the challenge of finding the right policy. With inadequate coverage leading to delayed treatments or worse, India’s citizens are left vulnerable. However, comprehensive insurance plans with essential features like no co-pay, pre- and post-hospitalization care, daycare treatment, and a robust hospital network can offer critical financial protection. This article evaluates and ranks India’s top health insurance policies, offering insights based on key criteria such as CSR, ICR, and essential policy features to help individuals make informed decisions.
Based on Nithin Kamath’s criteria—claim settlement ratio (CSR), network hospitals, incurred claim ratio (ICR), and key features like no co-pay, no room-rent restrictions, daycare treatments, pre- and post-hospitalisation care, restoration benefits, and customer satisfaction—the health insurance policies can be ranked as follows (However, I do not have any conflict of interest with any of these companies):
1. Max Bupa – Health Companion Family Floater Plan
- Claim Settlement Ratio: 96% (highest CSR).
- Network Hospitals: 5,000+ (decent but not the largest).
- ICR: 52% (good financial stability).
- Key Features: No room-rent limits, pre- and post-hospitalization cover, daycare treatments, restoration benefits, wellness programs, free health checkups.
- Why Best: Strong CSR, solid features, good financial stability, excellent customer satisfaction.
2. Star Health and Allied Insurance – Family Health Optima Plan
- Claim Settlement Ratio: 90%+.
- Network Hospitals: 11,000+ (largest network).
- ICR: 61%.
- Key Features: No co-pay, pre- and post-hospitalization coverage, restoration benefits, daycare treatments, free annual health checkups.
- Why Best: Excellent balance of CSR, features, and the largest hospital network.
3. Religare Care Health Insurance Plan
- Claim Settlement Ratio: 95%.
- Network Hospitals: 11,000+ (one of the largest).
- ICR: 55% (solid financial stability).
- Key Features: No co-pay, no disease-wise sub-limits, restoration benefits, daycare treatments, wellness bonuses, free health checkups.
- Why Best: High CSR, wide hospital network, and strong features for financial protection.
4. HDFC ERGO Health Insurance – Optima Restore Plan
- Claim Settlement Ratio: 93%.
- Network Hospitals: 10,000+ (strong network).
- ICR: 63%.
- Key Features: Restoration benefit, no co-pay, no disease-wise sub-limits, extensive pre- and post-hospitalization cover, domiciliary care.
- Why Best: Excellent CSR, strong network, well-rounded features, and restoration benefits.
5. ICICI Lombard – Complete Health Insurance Plan
- Claim Settlement Ratio: 85% (lower CSR but still good)
- Network Hospitals: 6,500+ (decent network)
- ICR: 70% (good financial stability)
- Key Features: No room-rent restrictions, pre- and post-hospitalization care, restoration benefits, wellness programs
- Why Best: Good balance between features and financial stability, though CSR is slightly lower.
6. SBI Health Insurance – Arogya Premier Plan
- Claim Settlement Ratio: 92%
- Network Hospitals: 6,000+ (good but smaller network)
- ICR: 75% (highest ICR, indicating financial stability)
- Key Features: No room-rent limits, pre- and post-hospitalization care, domiciliary care, daycare treatments, free health checkups
- Why Best: Strong CSR and features, but slightly smaller hospital network.
7. New India Assurance – Mediclaim Policy
- Claim Settlement Ratio: 91%
- Network Hospitals: 5,000+ (smallest network in the list)
- ICR: 60%
- Key Features: No co-pay, pre- and post-hospitalization care, daycare treatments, restoration benefits
- Why Best: Strong CSR and features but lack the large hospital network of the others.
Final Ranking:
- Max Bupa – Health Companion Family Floater Plan
- Star Health and Allied Insurance – Family Health Optima Plan
- Religare Care Health Insurance Plan
- HDFC ERGO Health Insurance – Optima Restore Plan
- ICICI Lombard – Complete Health Insurance Plan
- SBI Health Insurance – Arogya Premier Plan
- New India Assurance – Mediclaim Policy
This ranking reflects the balance between the key criteria outlined in the article, favouring strong claim settlement ratios, wide hospital networks, robust financial stability (ICR), and comprehensive policy features.
Dr. Prahlada N.B
MBBS (JJMMC), MS (PGIMER, Chandigarh).
MBA (BITS, Pilani), MHA,
Executive Programme in Strategic Management (IIM, Lucknow)
Senior Management Programme in Healthcare Management (IIM, Kozhikode)
Postgraduate Certificate in Technology Leadership and Innovation (MIT, USA)
Advanced Certificate in AI for Digital Health and Imaging Program (IISc, Bengaluru).
Senior Professor and former Head,
Department of ENT-Head & Neck Surgery, Skull Base Surgery, Cochlear Implant Surgery.
Basaveshwara Medical College & Hospital, Chitradurga, Karnataka, India.
My Vision: I don’t want to be a genius. I want to be a person with a bundle of experience.
My Mission: Help others achieve their life’s objectives in my presence or absence!
My Values: Creating value for others.
Leave a reply
Thank you, Prahlada Sir, for enlightening us on health insurance!
You've beautifully described the quest for the perfect policy in India, where medical expenses can be a financial time bomb waiting to unleash financial devastation! Like a skilled warrior, one must arm themselves with knowledge to navigate the treacherous landscape of healthcare inflation, rising at a staggering 14% annually.
Nitin Kamath's poignant statement, "one hospitalisation away from bankruptcy," echoes the harsh reality, a constant reminder of the fragility of our financial well-being.
To choose the best health insurance policy, as you have told one must be a discerning architect, carefully crafting a fortress of protection by considering these building blocks:
• Coverage: A sturdy umbrella
shielding us
from healthcare costs.
– Network Hospitals: A constellation of stars guiding us through medical uncertainty.
– Claim Settlement: A smooth-sailing ship navigating claim settlement.
– Premium: A gentle breeze soothing financial worries.
– Exclusions: A skilled cartographer mapping coverage terrain.
– Renewability: A loyal companion standing by us through thick and thin.
– Customer Support: A beacon of hope guiding us through healthcare complexities.
And my friend, you've curated a constellation of stellar options! Star Health Insurance shines bright like a North Star, guiding us through the vast sky of healthcare. ICICI Lombard sparkles like a diamond, its clarity and precision illuminating the path to comprehensive coverage. SBI Health Insurance stands tall like a majestic oak, its roots of trust and stability anchoring our well-being. And New India Assurance radiates like a sunrise, its warmth and promise of protection dispelling the shadows of uncertainty.
Each of these insurers offers a unique melody, and together, they create a symphony of security. Let us harmonize our needs with their offerings and compose a masterpiece of protection, tailored to our rhythm of life.
Reply